James Suckling 92 points - A red with lots of ripe dark fruits, mushroom and leaf aromas and flavors. Full body, silky tannins and a tasty, savory finish. Plenty of flavor. Drink now.
Vinous 88 points - The 2012 Vino Nobile di Montepulciano is decidedly ripe, flashy and opulent in style, with plenty of up-front fruit and early accessibility. The ripeness and radiance of the vintage come through in the wine’s exuberant personality. Drink this succulent Vino Nobile over the next handful of years.